Writers who are serious about publishing their work know the value of a critique group. A critique group involves writers of various genres who meet to discuss and give feedback. The goal is to produce the best polished work that is publisher-worthy and able to impact its readers.
The best critique groups begin and end with some sort of encouragement. Affirmations that the writer is on the right track or has included credible resources or has written an a-ha statement. It takes courage to bring a first draft to a critique group, and we all need to be encouraged in our creative efforts.
But constructive criticism is also offered. Something like: “Move this phrase up a paragraph. Give us more white space. A typo in line three. Are you certain about that research?”
Every manuscript needs another set of eyes reviewing it. And the best critiques offer valuable insights into what readers will expect when they open a book or find an article or follow a blog.
Writers must be teachable. Willing to learn and change. Ready to revise and grow. A writer who consistently argues his point and refuses to accept critique is not ready to be a published author. Because rejection is a side effect of writing. The best writing is rewriting, and even the pros revise their manuscripts multiple times.
An analogy begs to be offered. In our spiritual journeys, being teachable is also vital. We can all learn from more mature believers while a serious study of the Bible can bring new interpretations to past fallacies or cement beliefs we have long held.
Having an accountability partner or a spiritual director who can point out areas where we need to focus less on self and more on God. Being part of a viable spiritual community that cares about the teachings of Christ and not just the social aspects of group activities.
Knowing we can call on other pilgrims for comfort, resources, prayer, or empathy as we face the challenges of life. Then gathering together to observe the sacraments of worship, the Eucharist, the opportunities to serve and give, and the blessing of a benediction.
All these aspects of spiritual accountability help us polish our inner sanctum — the place where our souls reside and commune with the Divine Three.
Are critiques important? Indeed. For writers and for travelers on the spiritual highway. We need each other—in more ways than one.
©2026 RJ Thesman – All Rights Reserved
Follow Ruthie’s story as she learns about accountability on her road to grace. Seeking the Land of Grace.
I am 88 and still write each day. My work is mostly in the form of essays, collected in legacy volumes titled Outlook. Each volume is split into numbered publications of about 60 pages each. I have a local printer produce about ten copies of each volume. They are given to family or stored in my family home. Previously published books are available on Amazon under my name. My most current writing started about 2020, when my late wife contracted Alzheimer’s. The writing I did then helped me cope, and has become an emotionally supportive activity as I age. Rebecca has, and continues to be, an excellent editor and critic.
Thanks, Stu. I’m so glad you’re still writing every day! Your words matter.
Very thoughtful – thanks RJ.
Always good to hear from you, Evie!